Petroleum jelly doesn't add moisture. It forms a seal that keeps the moisture already in your skin from escaping. An aloe vera cream adds moisture and softens skin, and it rubs in without a greasy layer. They do different jobs, and they work well together: use a cream by day and add petroleum jelly over it on the driest spots at night.
Aloe vera cream vs petroleum jelly: the short version
| Petroleum jelly | Aloe vera cream | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A single occlusive ingredient that forms a water-resistant film5 | A water-and-oil cream made with aloe vera |
| Adds moisture? | No. It helps skin hold the moisture it already has4 | Yes. Water and humectants (ingredients that draw in moisture) add moisture; oils soften4 |
| Feel | Thick and greasy4 | Smooth; non-greasy creams exist |
| Often used for | An overnight seal on the driest spots, dry lips, spots where skin rubs1 | All-over daily moisture, hands during the day, face and body |
| A face that breaks out easily | Dermatologists suggest keeping it off1 | Look for a product labeled "noncomedogenic"4 (made not to clog pores) |
| Use together? | Yes, on top of a cream2 | Yes, underneath |
Is aloe vera petroleum jelly, or a different product?
Aloe vera and petroleum jelly are different. Aloe vera is a plant; petroleum jelly, also called petrolatum, is an ingredient that slows moisture loss. An aloe vera cream is a finished moisturizer. Check whether a comparison means aloe gel or a cream. See the difference between aloe gel and aloe cream.
What petroleum jelly does
Petroleum jelly seals in moisture
Petroleum jelly is an occlusive. It sits on the skin as a water-resistant film and slows the water loss from the skin's surface.5
Other occlusives used in skin care include lanolin (wool wax) and dimethicone (a silicone that forms a lighter film). Neither is in Corium 21.
That's why dermatologists rate it so highly for very dry skin. As dermatologist Caroline Robinson, MD, FAAD, puts it on the American Academy of Dermatology's site: "Petroleum jelly works by trapping existing moisture on your skin."2
Petroleum jelly doesn't add water
Occlusives "don't add moisture to your skin but help it hold onto the moisture it already has."4 So petroleum jelly works best over skin that's already damp or already moisturized.
Where dermatologists suggest petroleum jelly
The American Academy of Dermatology suggests petroleum jelly for very dry skin, including the lips, and for spots where skin rubs against skin or clothing.1
It also suggests keeping it off your face if your skin breaks out easily, because it may cause breakouts in some people.1
How petroleum jelly feels
Occlusives feel thick and greasy.4 Petroleum jelly can leave a shine and rub off on clothes and sheets, so bedtime, under socks or gloves, is an easy time to use it.
What an aloe vera cream does
An aloe vera cream adds moisture and softens
A cream combines water with ingredients that do different jobs. Humectants attract water to the skin and hold it there. Emollients soften and smooth.4
The result adds moisture, rubs in, and lets you get on with your day.
Humectants feel less thick and greasy than occlusives,4 so a cream spreads easily over arms, legs and hands, and you can get dressed or pick up your phone soon after.
What does petrolatum mean on a moisturizer label?
Petrolatum is another name for petroleum jelly. A product can contain it as one ingredient, so read the full list rather than assuming every cream has the same formula. Corium 21 lists certified organic aloe vera first. See the full ingredient list, or aloe vera compared with coconut oil.
Petrolatum is not in Corium 21; our petrolatum guide explains how it is refined and how it works on skin.
Where Corium 21 fits
We make Corium 21. It's a rich, smooth, non-greasy cream with certified organic aloe vera as its first ingredient.
Along with the aloe, it has vitamins A, B3 and E, soluble collagen, plant oils, and green tea, chamomile and ginseng extracts. See every ingredient.
Aloe vera vs petroleum jelly: is one better?
Neither one is better across the board. They do different jobs.
Petroleum jelly seals moisture in. An aloe vera cream adds moisture and softens.
Dermatologists list petrolatum (petroleum jelly) among good ingredients for dry skin.3 If you want an everyday, all-over moisturizer that rubs in, a cream fits that job. If you want the heaviest overnight seal on a very dry spot, petroleum jelly does that job.
How to use aloe vera cream and petroleum jelly together on very dry hands, heels and elbows
- Wash, then pat skin until it's just damp. Moisturizer works best on damp skin.3
- Smooth on the cream. Our customers tell us they just use a dab. A little bit goes a long way.
- At night, seal the driest spots. Add a thin layer of petroleum jelly over the cream on heels, elbows or knuckles.2
- Cover up. Pull on cotton socks or gloves so it stays put and stays off your sheets.
For a step-by-step version for feet, see the cotton-socks routine for dry heels. For hands, see dry hands.
When people reach for aloe vera cream or petroleum jelly
An aloe vera cream
- Daytime moisture for face and body
- Under makeup
- Hands that touch paper, keyboards or phone screens
- After every hand wash
Petroleum jelly
- An overnight seal on the driest spots
- Dry lips (more on lips)
- Spots where skin rubs (more on rubbing)
Aloe vera cream or petroleum jelly: if you only buy one
For everyday, all-over use on face, hands and body, a cream is usually easier to live with. It adds moisture, rubs in, and doesn't leave a greasy layer on your hands.
If your skin is fine most of the day but a few spots get very dry, add petroleum jelly at night over your cream on just those spots.
Neither choice is wrong. Pick the one you'll actually use every day. Dermatologists suggest moisturizing several times a day and right after washing.3
Aloe vera cream vs petroleum jelly: questions people ask
Is aloe vera better than petroleum jelly?
Neither is better across the board. Petroleum jelly seals in moisture. An aloe vera cream adds moisture and softens, and the two work well together.
Is aloe vera the same as petroleum jelly?
No. Petroleum jelly is a single ingredient that seals in moisture. Aloe vera is a plant, and an aloe vera cream blends aloe with water and oils.
Is petrolatum another name for petroleum jelly?
Petrolatum is another name for petroleum jelly. It can be listed as an ingredient in a finished moisturizer.
Petroleum jelly or aloe vera for dry skin?
Use an aloe vera cream for daily moisture and petroleum jelly to seal very dry spots. At night, you can use both: the cream first, then petroleum jelly on top.
Can I put petroleum jelly over aloe vera cream?
Yes. Dermatologists suggest applying petroleum jelly on top of a lotion or cream.2
Can I use petroleum jelly on my face?
Dermatologists suggest keeping petroleum jelly off your face if it breaks out easily.1 A cream may suit everyday face use better.
Does Corium 21 contain petroleum jelly?
No. Corium 21's full label ingredient list has no petroleum jelly (petrolatum) and no mineral oil. Its first ingredient is certified organic aloe vera.
Is Corium 21 greasy?
No. Corium 21 is rich and smooth, with a non-greasy finish.
Try Corium 21
Free Samples are two small jars, one Classic Fragrance and one Fragrance Free, the same formula without the fragrance. You pay shipping only. Or shop the 8 oz jar.
Every size is covered by our 90-day promise, opened jars included: one refund per customer, and Free Samples aren't covered. See Our Promise. For children under 2, check with a doctor before using.
Trusted since 1994. Family-owned in Oregon. Call (800) 319-5114, and you'll talk to a real person.
More reading: how to choose an aloe vera cream for dry skin, aloe vera cream vs gel, and aloe cream for very dry skin.
Sources
-
American Academy of Dermatology, 5 ways to use petroleum jelly for skin care, https://www.aad.org/public/everyday-care/skin-care-secrets/routine/petroleum-jelly.
-
American Academy of Dermatology, Dry skin remedies for darker skin tones, https://www.aad.org/public/darker-skin/secrets/dry-skin/dry-skin-remedies-darker-skin.
-
American Academy of Dermatology, Dermatologists' top tips for dry skin, https://www.aad.org/public/everyday-care/skin-care-basics/dry/dermatologists-tips-relieve-dry-skin.
-
Cleveland Clinic, Emollients, https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/23305-emollients.
-
DermNet, Emollients and moisturisers, https://dermnetnz.org/topics/emollients-and-moisturisers.
Corium 21 ingredients: Ingredients.
